Dvader said:

aspro said:

Wait a second.

Shouldn't the runner-up of this round be the next one you play? Sleeping Dogs?

No thats not how it works, at the end of the voting a whole new category comes up. The games will show up later but its a fresh vote each time.

I think it's better this way Vader.  It gives more gravity to the vote.  I vote for The Thing because I love the movie.  I haven't played the game though I have a PS2 copy here somewhere.

5 votes for The Thing

1 vote SH Homecoming

1 vote Deadly Premonition

This one seems like a landslide. You can chage your votes if you ever feel like it, it will take a few days to beat Bully.

I'm starting to think GME is right about everything as he was spot on about the platformers and the GTA game (at least so far, I agree with his take on Bully). If he is right about this horror category GME is going to get his own category of just games he recommends.

edgecrusher said:

I can't listen to anyone who thinks those new Silent Hill games are good.

The main thing about a horror game that makes it good is the atmosphere, and Homecoming really delivers it in spades. It also has great monster design, functional fun combat, and a pretty good story. (though all Silent Hill games have that)

When you are running around the city and the power goes out, and the street lights are gone, and the fog goes apeshit and all you hear are growls and things moving it is nuts. That game had a nice design in that it knew when to crank up the fear and keep it going and knew when to let you breathe for a second too, great pacing. Good sountrack as well, although I would say not quite as good as the older games soundtracks still a bar above a lot of games though.

Lastly it was just fun to play. They take the crappy combat and make it ok, they make some interesting designed levels like the ruined hotel and prison which were both well done. Did you play it yourself? What didn't you like?

Edit> Just also want to say that I don't think the game was quite as good as the old ones (Silent Hill 1 <3   but it is a great horror title in it's own right. So vader temper expecations a little (if you ever play it) but I would still score it an 8/10

edgecrusher said:

You don't think The Thing has great atmosphere?

Look maybe you were sick at the time you played it or some magical dwarf put a spell on you or some shit....in fact yes GME this is what I choose to believe happened to you.

It's the only reasonable explanation.

Dvader said:

He never specifically says the thing doesn't have great atmosphere.

Yes but he says the main thing that makes a great horror game is its atmosphere, but calls the Thing out to be complete shit. lol

Bulletstorm by a MILE.

Bulletstorm

Ravenprose said:

Rage.

Hasn't Vader suffered enough?

aspro said:

Hasn't Vader suffered enough?

thank you for protecting me.

The thing seems really cool so far. It is very old school in controls and how it's more open than current games. That is great for me as I grew up on these games. Good choice, aspro you are in for some old school horror goodness.

BTW it is INSANE the difference in how old games look on the 360 compared to wii u, this game looks HD. WTF is wrong with Nintendo, why can't they do the same thing?