Dvader said:

Have any of you even tried a FPS with the wiimote?

Yes. I have played:

• Metroid Prime 3
• Red Steel
• Red Steel 2
• Call of Duty 3
• The Conduit
• Far Cry Vengence (awful game, even the mightly dual-analogue controls would not have saved this travesty)

I'd rather have played all of them with a dual-analogue controller. In the case of Metroid Prime 3, I'd rather it had Gamecube controls just like Metroid Prime.

Ravenprose said:

Yes. I have played:

• Metroid Prime 3
• Red Steel
• Red Steel 2
• Call of Duty 3
• The Conduit
• Far Cry Vengence (awful game, even the mightly dual-analogue controls would not have saved this travesty)

I'd rather have played all of them with a dual-analogue controller. In the case of Metroid Prime 3, I'd rather it had Gamecube controls just like Metroid Prime.

Opinion valid, I respect your decision.

OMG.

phantom_leo said:

Which trails, naturally, behind A Link to the Past.

Which all trail behind the original. So there.

Dvader said:

Which all trail behind the original. So there.

Which was eclipsed by Link's Awakening.

Archangel3371 said:

If the Metroid Prime games count then yes I have played an FPS game with the Wii-mote. Regardless you said ALL games should be IR and to that I said, and still say, NO. Using one genre to try and prove this proves nothing. So therefore, you sir, have FAILED. I say, GOOD DAY.

besides fighting games  and hack and slash what wouldn't be better with ir

SteelAttack said:

eggmiester said:

besides fighting games  and hack and slash what wouldn't be better with ir

Racers, platformers, action games, RPGs.

guitar hero et al.

gamingeek said:

Yeah,  but whose reviews do you trust these days? With me it varies on each game, I don't particularly trust any one site.

I trust my own reviews. All others are not helpful when it comes to my opinion of a game.

Archangel3371 said:

If the Metroid Prime games count then yes I have played an FPS game with the Wii-mote. Regardless you said ALL games should be IR and to that I said, and still say, NO. Using one genre to try and prove this proves nothing. So therefore, you sir, have FAILED. I say, GOOD DAY.

Metroid Prime 3 certainly is.

eggmiester said:

aspro said:

guitar hero et al.

people still play the bad music games thats insane i thought they would have died out like ddr should have

I don't think too many people do anymore -- didn't GH sell like < 100,000 in it's opening week this year? (as opposed to 500,000 in the opening week 2 years ago).  I think Rock Band is still popular, we'll have to wait until next months sales figures.  I think GH is dead.  I just picked up GH5 for $15 and am playing it now and it's not too much fun -- a lot like DDR in it's waning days -- when you realize all the tricks and that it's the same old thing time and time again.

Archangel3371 said:

If the Metroid Prime games count then yes I have played an FPS game with the Wii-mote. Regardless you said ALL games should be IR and to that I said, and still say, NO. Using one genre to try and prove this proves nothing. So therefore, you sir, have FAILED. I say, GOOD DAY.

Damn you! You are correct, I wrote that wrong. I meant all FPSs.