I was sick as a dog this weekend, so I didn't get to update like I wanted to.  So here is my top five without a write up.

1.Resident Evil 4

2.Dead Space

3. Eternal Darkness

4. Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare

5. Maniac Mansion

I loved Eternal Darkness at the time and still do but I find it surprising it lists among peoples favourite survival horrors. Is it because there are so few good ones?

It's been dominated by Silent Hill and RE for so long.

Where does the Evil Within sit on peoples lists?

All right, better late than never, I guess.  Sorry, no excuses, life got ahead of me.  The VGPress scariest games are:

4. (Tie) Silent Hill/ Silent Hill 2

3. Resident Evil

2. Resident Evil 2

And......shock!

1. RESIDENT EVIL4!!

travo said:

All right, better late than never, I guess.  Sorry, no excuses, life got ahead of me.  The VGPress scariest games are:

4. (Tie) Silent Hill/ Silent Hill 2

3. Resident Evil

2. Resident Evil 2

And......shock!

1. RESIDENT EVIL4!!

I call foul, the vote was supposed to be about the "best horror games" yet you have only counted votes for the "scariest games".

I'm getting Dick Pound (real name) to investigate you like the IAAF.

Worse still, Silent Hill 1 and 2 were beaten by 3 Resident Evil games as "scariest" games, with the least scary Resident Evil coming in at first...

aspro said:

Gagan said:

Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of The Earth.

Did you play it on XB? And if so did you get past the fisheries section?

PC, and yes I've beaten the game.