gamingeek said:No I mean I can't even begin to compare an arcade racer to a platformer. I would not even try to vote.
It's not comparing apples to oranges, it's making a choice between an apple and an orange. We do this all the time when we go to our respective fridges.
aspro said:It's not comparing apples to oranges, it's making a choice between an apple and an orange. We do this all the time when we go to our respective fridges.
Perfect analogy. We are not comparing anything, we are simply determining our favorite game of the decade in a cool NCAA tournament style. Each matchup gives a nice glimpse into every voter and how they think.
Day 3 Results
Match 17: Super Mario Galaxy wins 10-0
Match 18: Littlebigplanet wins 6-4
Match 19: Zelda Oracle wins 6-4
Match 20: Fallout 3 wins 7-3
Match 21: Diablo 2 wins 6-4
Match 22: World of Warcraft wins 9-1
Match 23: Mass Effect wins 6-4
Match 24: Skies of Arcadia wins 6-5
Need a tiebreaker for Zelda Wind Waker and Skies of Arcadia.
Holy crap GTA4 got beat down. MGS4 lost. 
Match 25:
vs. 
Match 26:
vs. 
Match 27:
vs. 
Match 28:
vs. 
Match 29:
vs. 
Match 30:
vs. 
Match 31:
vs. 
Match 32:
vs. 
Match 25: Uncharted 2
Match 26: Smash Bros
Match 27: SotC
Match 28: Batman
Match 29: Metroid Prime
Match 30: Deus Ex
Match 31: GTA SA
Match 32: MGS2
- Uncharted 2
- Brawl
- Shadow of the Colossus
- Batman AA
- Metroid Prime
- Deus Ex
- Resident Evil 5
- Valkyria Chronicles
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now Playing: Golden Sun Dark Dawn, God of War Ghost of Sparta, and DKC Returns
Match 25: Uncharted 2.
Match 26: CoD4.
Match 27: SotC.
Match 28: Batman: AA
Match 29: Metroid Prime
Match 30: Deus Ex
Match 31: GTA: SA
Match 32: Valkyria Chronicles
Match 32:
UNCHARTED 2
CoD 4
VF5 (I don't like Moby)
ARKHAM!
Prime
Shenmue 2
GTASA (Grove Street for LIFE)
MGS2
Match 25:
Uncharted 2 I suppose.
Match 26:
BrawlMatch 27:
SotC.
Match 28:
THPS3. 
Match 29:
Metroid Prime.
Match 30:
Deus Ex.
Match 31:
San Andreas
Match 32:
MGS2.
Ravenprose said:Match 25: Uncharted 2
Match 26: COD4
Match 27: VF5
Match 28: Batman
Match 29: Metroid Prime
Match 30: Deus Ex
Match 31: RE5
Match 32: N/A
I never keep apples and oranges in the fridge.
26. Modern Warfare
27. Virtua Fighter 5
28. Batman AA
29. Metroid Prime
30. Deus Ex
31. Resident Evil 5
32. Metal Gear Solid 2
gamingeek said:I never keep apples and oranges in the fridge.
You should. They will last longer.
gamingeek said:I vote for Zelda: Wind Waker.
Thanks GG. You solved our tie issue. 
Dvader said:gamingeek said:I vote for Zelda: Wind Waker.
Thanks GG. You solved our tie issue.
You son of a bitch, you didn't want to vote and when you do vote you come up with this? *rage*
Dvader said:Day 3 Results
Match 17: Super Mario Galaxy wins 10-0
Match 18: Littlebigplanet wins 6-4
Match 19: Zelda Oracle wins 6-4
Match 20: Fallout 3 wins 7-3
Match 21: Diablo 2 wins 6-4
Match 22: World of Warcraft wins 9-1
Match 23: Mass Effect wins 6-4
Match 24: Zelda Wind Waker wins 6-5
Fallout 3? Really? Wind Wanker over Skies?
Super Mario Galaxy
Final Fantasy XII
Zelda Oracle Series
Fallout 3
Diablo II
World of Warcraft
Rocket Slime
Skies of Arcadia