Gagan said:

I'm way past Bloody baron, I'm on skelliga, and I don't think between the 3 of us we are that far off, neither of us are willing to call it good for instance lol. My thing is I wouldn't go all the way with calling it mechanically poor as much as some of the encounter design is jsut fucking stupid, based on the limitations Geralt has, some of these scenarios shouldn't have made it past play testing. Which my guess is that they are a total push over for most of the games other difficulty settings, so no one really cared to notice.

I wouldn't say it's mechanically bad, a few tweaks here and there or a better do use enemy combat patterns and it would be very good. Yeah like you said enemy encounter design is crappy.